Payroll Service Comparison Chart
Black Box Business Services |
Software
(such as QuickBooks®) |
Other Payroll Services (such as ADP® / PayChex®) |
|
Access |
You can run payroll from any computer with internet access (OR we can do everything for you, once you send us hours). |
You must use the computer where your accounting/payroll software is installed. |
You must make yourself available to submit hours by phone or online. |
Setup |
We do the set up for you, there's nothing to install on your end. |
Software and tax table updates required. No help with new hire reporting, W-4s, I-9s. |
Paper-intensive manual process. |
Email Reminders |
Timely email reminders remind you of all important deadlines. |
Online reminders exist, but they are not automated. |
No reminders available. |
Paycheck calculations |
Instant and guaranteed accurate. |
Instant and guaranteed accurate (but requires ongoing tax table updates). |
Paycheck calculations are delayed from the time you report hours. |
Direct Deposit |
Free |
Extra charges apply. |
Extra charges apply. |
Paychecks |
Print instantly on blank or pre-printed check stock - either at our office or yours. |
No blank check printing option. |
Delivered to your office for an extra fee. |
Tax Impounding |
No tax impounding- funds stay in your bank account until the payment is due. |
Depends on service selected. |
Taxes are withdrawn on each payday, typically several weeks before they are due. |
Electronic tax payments and filings |
Electronic 940s, 941s, 944s, W-2s, and e-file for most states (or we provide signature-ready forms). |
Electronic functionality available for 941s, and very few states. |
The service takes care of taxes for you, for an extra fee. |
Customer Support |
Free. As your trusted advisor, we're here to help you whenever you have a question. |
Extra charges apply. |
Included |
Export |
Easy data download to QuickBooks®, QuickBooks Online, QuickBooks® for Mac, Microsoft Money® and Quicken®. |
Works only with QuickBooks. |
Downloads data to QuickBooks, but as journal lump-sum. There are no split level details available. |
Price |
As low as $ 49.95 |
Pricing can vary greatly by service selected. |
Pricing varies by no. of employees and payroll runs. Additional fees for direct deposit, quarterly filings, delivery fees, W-2s etc. |